Capitalism Vs. Communism: An Everlasting Debate
There is a long-running debate about whether communism or capitalism is preferable and shows more of beneficial aspects. Capitalism is defined as an economic system in which investment in and ownership of the means of production, distribution, and exchange of wealth is made and maintained chiefly by private individuals or corporations. While communism is a system of social organization in which all economic and social activity is controlled by the state. The principle of capitalism is if one is successful and hardworking will keep improve and progress in life. While the principle of communism is to keep all the people the same, a lot of people may say that this is a good thing but when talking about real life this would add laziness and demotivation because hardworking people would gain the same credit as lazy people. Capitalism and communism are the two main economic systems that are used by governments nowadays. Obviously capitalism is a much better economic system to be used by a state; practical uses and statistical facts qualify capitalism as much more successful. Also, capitalism is more beneficial to the state, common citizens, and business owners. It would be very useful to test the two systems according to practical uses of the two systems on states and monitor which states succeeded and which states failed.
One of the best ways to end the capitalism-communism debate is by testing the two systems practically in real life uses. For example, USA and Germany are two economic superpowers that use capitalist based economy; USA has the best economy in the world and the highest GDP ($15.68 trillion) in the world while Germany is ranked the fourth country in highest GDP (3.4 trillion). China and North Korea are two communist countries, although China is an economic superpower it is said to be economically overrated as its GDP is $ 9, 020,309 million while the GDP per capita is $ 6,091. Chinese citizens are extremely poor relative to their country's enormous GDP that’s why china is said to be economically overrated. Bill Gates the well-known billionaire said "capitalism has worked very well. Anyone who wants to move to North Korea is welcome. In this quote bill gates wanted to describe the communism failure particularly in North Korea. North Korea's economy is in depression around 1-3 million people have died in famine that began in the mid-1990s also they face major economic problems like unemployment and accumulated debts. Although communism main principle is that wealth is distributed equally to the people, most of North Korea's population is starving to death. It is clear that communism is a failure when testing it practically and with statistical facts.
Capitalist states (also known as free economy) don’t interfere in the economy as much as communist states (also known as planned economy), this would help the country to use its recourses more efficiently and also to concentrate more on its political issues and help the country to...
Loading: Checking Spelling0%
The Fall of Socialism Essay3223 words - 13 pages The Fall of Socialism Ever since the Great Depression, political and economic thought in America has moved consistently to the right, enough that reforms which passed years ago in other industrialized countries cannot even be mentioned in political discussion. In fact, there is a deliberate destruction of legitimate thought by equating it with a universal evil. Specifically, any reform which helps the lower classes - reforms such as welfare,...
Truman vs. MacArthur Essay979 words - 4 pages Truman vs. MacArthur The Korean War changed the face of American Cold War diplomacy forever. In the midst of all the political conflict and speculation worldwide, the nation had to choose between two proposed solutions, each one hoping to ensure that communism didn?t sweep across the globe and destroy American ideals of capitalism and democracy. General Douglas MacArthur takes the pro-active stance and says that, assuming it has the...
Socialism versus Capitalism in The Jungle by Upton Sinclair1662 words - 7 pages Socialism versus Capitalism in The Jungle by Upton Sinclair Even before the beginning of the twentieth century, the debate between socialists and capitalists has raged. In The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair, he portrays capitalism as the cause of all evils in society. Sinclair shows the horrors of capitalism. In The Gospel of Wealth, by Andrew Carnegie, he portrays capitalism as a system of opportunity. However, both Carnegie and Sinclair had...
China6806 words - 27 pages Alone I stand in the autumn cold On the tip of Orange Island, The Xiang flowing northward; I see a thousand hills crimsoned through By their serried woods deep-dyed, And a hundred barges vying Over crystal blue waters. Eagles cleave the air, Fish glide under the shallow water; Under freezing skies a million creatures contend in freedom. Brooding over this immensity, I ask, on this bondless land Who rules over man's destiny? -----Mao Zedong...
The First Industrial Revolution1062 words - 4 pages Part A. The two most significant social consequences of the First Industrial Revolution (c. 1780-1850) are urbanization and child labor. Because people moved from rural areas into cities, the living conditions changed for the worse and with the invention of the steam-operated power loom in 1785, children were able to operate this simple machine and produce textiles for the exploding population ("Begins," n.d.). The Industrial Revolution began...
Compare and Contrast essay Capitalism V. Communism817 words - 3 pages As the feudal system in Europe began crumbling with the dawn of the Industrial Revolution a void was created in the European social and economic structure, Scottish philosopher Adam Smith took it upon himself to fill this void and in 1776 published The Wealth of Nations; just as Newtons Principia Mathematica laid the foundation for modern physics so to...
Darwin’s Theory of Natural Selection and Social Darwinism790 words - 3 pages Darwin and Evolution are inextricably linked in the minds of most people who have had the opportunity to study them in basic biology. However, Darwin's theories of selection and survival of the fittest have been applied to moral, economic, political, and other cultural aspects of society. Dennett briefly touched on some of the political and social ramifications of Darwin's theories in the final chapter of Darwin's Dangerous Idea. Other...
Economic Systems: Socialism and Capitalism1289 words - 5 pages I have observed that when Americans discuss the relative merits of socialism vs. capitalism, the chief debates that come up are • What would happen if we remove the stimulus for innovation and productivity that a free market generates? This implies having a free market including individual ownership and control, and to varying degrees a laissez-faire government. • Would it be possible to have a thriving society in which we would not have 20% of...
Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx.955 words - 4 pages Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx, living in the typical capitalist community in the United States, it is much easier to relate to the thoughts of Adam Smith. This is not to say that I do not agree with some of the precepts of pure Communism, but like the old...
Russia2135 words - 9 pages 14/08/14 10:39The BeginningSince the French Revolution, Liberalism was the leading political system that was sweeping Europe and the Americas. Liberal DemocraciesAll citizens had equal...
Democracy Vs Communism537 words - 2 pages Communism vs DemocracyCommunism is an original system of society, quite different from Democracy in many ways. While total democracy is not widely spread, many forms of it are prosperous throughout the world today.One of the first and major differences between a Communist and Democratic government is their contrary economic systems. In a communist government,...
Comparing Communism and Capitalism
- Length: 1032 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)
- Rating: Excellent
Communism vs. Capitalism
In Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto, he describes the Communists as the party that "fights for the interests of the working class"(136), while in a Capitalist society, the "living person is dependent and has no individuality-----only capital is dependent and has individuality"(84). That is not the case of today's society once you take a closer view at the comparison and contrast of communist Vietnam versus the democratic United States of America through their economy systems, educational systems, judicial systems, and the life style of their citizens in general.
In a capitalist, democratic nation such as the U.S., freedom gives us just about everything and anything that the Vietnamese do not have under their communist government. Contrary to what Karl Marx has written in his manifesto, the living people of a capitalist nation (i.e. USA) of today are more independent and possess more individualities than ever. Economic-wise, Americans are the most progressive people in the world. The U.S. government is not directing the flow of its economy, but the individual businesses of its people are. These people have all the rights in the world to improve their businesses, as long as they are conducting them under the legal guidelines of the government. Such freedom in a capitalist society gives the Americans much greater advantages over the Vietnamese in improving economic conditions.
When we touch upon the subject of education, only eighty percent of Vietnam's population is educated. The government does not provide free public education to its people, and not everyone is fortunate enough to be able to afford it. Many children, especially those in the rural areas, are pulled out of schools as soon as they know how to read and write, for some parents also feel that learning Marxism-Leninism does not benefit their families' income, i.e., putting food in their mouth. Further education is really not an option, for these children also have to work in order to raise their families. Begging in the streets, polishing shoes, toiling on the farms are some of the many jobs that children at the age of five are actively doing, since finding food for themselves and their families is their sole occupation. Fortunately, children in many capitalist nations are provided with adequate tools and supplies in their public schools. Almost all of the American population has at least passed the elementary and middle school levels.
How to Cite this Page
|A Comparison of Communism versus Capitalism Essay - A Comparison of Communism versus Capitalism Communism versus Capitalism is a debate that has raged on for over two centuries. Whether to allow everyone equal opportunities and to do with those opportunities as they please or to mandate class equality in order to keep peace has in itself been the cause of wars. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels saw the working class of the world--the proletariat--being squashed by the greedy business owners--the bourgeoisie. In their view, the bourgeoisie owned too much and the proletariat had no chance to make their own fortunes.... [tags: Compare Contrast Comparing]||700 words|
|Essay about Comparing Socialism and Communism - The life in the U.S compared to that of the Soviet Union during the 60’s is an amazing phenomenon of a declining life expectancy in a highly developed country just like in the case of the Soviet Union during the 60’s down to the 70’s. The result of the life expectancy rate in the Soviet Union shows that there is only a small part to true informal changes in the state of living. However, the weak point of the measures of life expectancy is of vital importance, although another factor is the unfavourable selection of risks by war, thereby making a less valuable comparison between the international and inter temporal.... [tags: Socialism vs Communism ]||703 words|
|Capitalism vs. Communism Essay - Capitalism vs. Communism For many years the United States as looked upon communism as an evil and must not spread to other countries. The Cold War is a perfect example of this; we spent 40 years in terror due to this way of thinking. Now we understand that communism is not an evil just another way of organizing a country. Capitalism and Communism has its own ideas on how a government should run, whether it’s through advancement of people According to Minsky capitalism is not just the market economy, but it is also a financial economy (1).... [tags: Compare Conrast Comparison]||749 words|
| Essay about Capitalism in the US - The United States of America is a great country. It is possibly the longest standing free nation in the history of the world. The founding fathers that constructed our form of government and the Constitution were genius minds. Our republic was founded with an economic system, which we call capitalism. Unfortunately, capitalism is under attack today in the United States. The U.S. must return quickly to a pure capitalist financial system or risk economic ruin. Capitalism is what made our country strong, and it needs to be protected from its enemies.... [tags: History, Benefits, Attack]|
:: 3 Works Cited
| Communism and Capitalism: Strange Bedfellows Essay - What is it about communism that makes many people scurry and cringe. In America, the mere word might as well be banned from the dictionary. The only time it is used is when talking about new aggressive movements by totalitarian communist countries. American’s tolerance level for communism is zero to none. Is communism so horrific that the thought of some forms being successful is out of the question. In society today, capitalism is the leading economic system. When compared to other systems, few meet its standards of living.... [tags: Capitalism vs Communism]|
:: 19 Works Cited
| Comparing and Contrasting the Social & Economic Systems of Western and Eastern Europe - The economic and social systems of Western Europe and the Soviet Eastern bloc in 1945-1955 were very different yet very similar in several ways. The East was definitely trying to reconcile with the West, whereas the West wasn’t as in to interacting with the East after World War II. Based on my new found knowledge of both the West and East of Europe, I can say that from an economic aspect, both received very different treatment from different countries. Because of the Soviet Union’s socialism, countries such as the United States viewed them negatively because of disagreeing opinions on socialism.... [tags: Marshall Plan, USSR, socialism, capitalism]|
:: 15 Works Cited
| Essay on Capitalism vs Communism - “Necessity, who is the mother of invention” (Plato), but profit doesn’t hurt either. Until the First Industrial Revolution manual labor was the way of the world. The great societies of the world like the Greeks and the Romans built their empires with their hands. With the inventions during 1780-1850, machinery and innovation gave way to less manual labor. Marketing was born during this time because these new inventions needed to be sold to the public. Capitalism thrived with these inventions and mechanization was on the rise.... [tags: Capitalism vs Communism]|
:: 5 Works Cited
|Comparing Hitler's Germany and Stalin's Russia Essay - Comparing Hitler's Germany and Stalin's Russia Why is it that Germany's fascism lasted a relatively short time compared to Russia's communism. The regimes established under Hitler and Stalin were incredibly similar with respect to the rise and control of the state. Both systems were based on entirely different ideology and goals. Hitler's Mein Kampf established the superiority of the German race and the need to expand as wanted by God. Hitler wanted the world. The government in Russia established by Lenin was based on a book called Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx, a call to the proletariate to unite and rebel against their selfish employers.... [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]||966 words|
|Communism vs Capitalism Essay - Capitalism vs. Communism Throughout history, there have been many systems developed in order to have a better society. Two of the most analyzed, and debated systems that have tired to change an economy for the best are communism, and capitalism. Communism, and capitalism have been compared on many levels, such as why they will or will not work, and which one works better. Throughout this essay I will concentrate on the differences, and similarities of how each operates, along with the benefits, and problems that each of them produces.... [tags: Communism Essays]||842 words|
| Capitalism vs Communism Essay - Poverty is everywhere and no matter how hard our government tries to eliminate it, it simply cannot. To do so it must first reformat itself so that it may do its job in a more efficient manor, thus helping all aspects of life. Converting our current system into a capitalistic government would in fact help alleviate the current situation. Contrary to widely held beliefs, capitalism is not a system which exploits a large portion of society for the sake of a small minority. Capitalism is an economic system characterized by the freedom of the market with increasing concentration of the private and corporate ownership of production and distribution means.... [tags: Communism Essays]|
:: 2 Works Cited
Capitalism Communism Educational Systems Democratic Nation Capitalist Society Rural Areas Economic Conditions U.s. Government Working Class Public Education
College students who are in financial need do not have to worry much since the government is willing to give out grants and provide loans that can be paid back later on. Under Communism, education is really not as beneficial to an individual as it would be for someone living under a democratic society. In Vietnam for example, a job is still hard to find even if you possess a Masters degree in some sort of area. Again, you would either need some kind of connection with a higher authority, or you would have to work for the communist government.
In a communist nation, the judicial system can be very flexible at times. Crimes are rarely committed under such watchful eyes as the Communists, and the result of any crime would also be too harsh to bear. Safety is probably the best thing that the Communists can provide, but it can also be reversed anytime. By reversing, I mean that some people can also be convicted for not doing anything wrong. As long as someone (a local government cadre) possesses some sort of power, that person has all the right to convict you of anything that they want---yes, even without proof. On the other hand, the system also provides some safety to its people. Unlike in the U.S., crimes such as murdering, raping, robbing, and many others rarely or not even ever occur in communist Vietnam. People do not get away with them as easily as they do in America. There is no such thing as death row or parole in communist nations. Crimes are paid for immediately after they are convicted. Prisons do not have installed televisions nor nice beds for criminals. These prisoners have to earn the food that they eat by doing a certain amount of work for the time that they are sentenced to stay. Overall, the Communists1/4 judicial system works very well comparing to the one possessed by the Americans.
In a communist society, the citizens are a pretty much close-knit group. In countries such as Vietnam or China, most neighbors would know one another for many generations. Close friends treat each other as if they are their own family members. Families that are in the middle-upper to the upper classes can afford to live in brick houses, while the rest of the population (which consists of mostly middle-lower to lower classes) stay in wooden or even straw shelters (they are not really houses but more like shacks). Every corner you turn, poverty claims its existence. "Malnutrition and starvation are very common"(Editorial 2). Unlike a democratic society, freedom of speech does not take place in a communist society. Everything you do or say is being watched by government cadres or their spies (the Red Scare). In a capitalist society such as the Americans, family values do not exist in very many households; while in a communist nation such as Vietnam, "the family's sentimental veil"(Marx 24) remains despite the poor living condition in which many low-income families face.
Given these actual facts, Communism proves to not be particularly evil but can also be beneficial, too. On the same token, it limits the freedom and individuality that make someone who they really are. Even though Capitalism does satisfy individuality, yet, it tears away the ideal practices of family values and moral values, altogether. One cannot say that either Communism or Capitalism is healthy or unhealthy, because both of their existence place positive and negative effects on any present society.
Dam, Julie. "Release." The Gioi 16 Nov. 1995: 37-43.
Tran, Ha Nhu Ana. "Summer of Love.3/4 1997. http://www.realsaigon.com/feature/summer/summer.htm (24 Jun. 1997).
Editorial. "The Vietnamese Generation X.3/4 Apr. 1995. http://www.vinsight.org/0495/genx.html (25 Jun. 1997).
Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. "The Communist Manifesto.3/4 http://www.leftside.uvc.ac.za/Archives/1848-CM/cm.html (25 Jun. 1997).